- Messages
- 4,493
- Location
- North America
@ Buddha - 6 or 7 years ago when compacts first came out or became more popular, there were issues with a very popular Brand UVB bulb's Compact version, which in fact is not really a coil fluorescent style at all. Because the tube was\is so popular and has always had good reviews, people confused the issue with another because the brand names are so close. The stories started that the Repti-Glo compact was the bad apple & just snowballed, escalated to all Rept-Glo bulbs including the tubes. When in truth, this is the report from uvguide.uk.co, that started it all ...
On another Forum the false issues concerning the Repti-Glo bulbs were again being thrown out there, Frances Baines was a member so I queried her on her findings & reports to uvguide.uk.co. This was her reply ...
Now all that being said, personally I have never been a fan of Compacts, have always used tubes because I have always mounted the fixtures inside the enclosures. Compacts have their place, just not in any of 'my' enclosures .
Don't know if that actually answers your question or not, but that's all I got .
uvguide.uk.co at the time was 'the place' when it came to UV lighting for herps & are responsible for many, many improvements to the bulbs we use today. Unfortunately the site was down for a major upgrade & has not been updated now for a couple of years. I heard rumors that Frances Baines fell under serious health issues since, but don't quote me on that, again only rumors.We began a serious investigation of these reports in April 2007 following an alert from one of the organisers of a popular hobbyists’ website forum in the USA, www.redearslider.com, where members had become very concerned following a spate of problems in turtles across the USA.
We have now documented 40 individual cases, occurring since September 2006, affecting 16 turtles, 3 tortoises and 21 lizards in the USA and in Europe, affected by ZooMed Reptisun 10.0 Compact Lamps and (more rarely) 5.0 Compact Lamps.
http://www.uvguide.co.uk/phototherapyphosphor.htm
On another Forum the false issues concerning the Repti-Glo bulbs were again being thrown out there, Frances Baines was a member so I queried her on her findings & reports to uvguide.uk.co. This was her reply ...
As far as I know, the Issues with the Repti-Sun compact has long since been rectified by using different phosphors in their manufacture. Yet, This stigmatism still plagues Repti-Glo's reputation. I have used Repti-glo tubes for many years without issue, since day 1, this past year or so I have used the Repti-Sun tubes because I got a very good buy on a larger order of them & wanted to try them out. I just installed the last one. I have not noticed any difference whatsoever between the 2 brands of bulbs. All my remaining enclosures with the new juveniles, will now, once again, have Repti-Glo 10.0 tubes, as soon as they arrive this week.However there are only a very few reports of photo-kerato-conjunctivitis associated with ExoTerra compact lamps or linear tubes ...and out of the half-dozen or so convincing cases I've collected over five years, (yeah, ok, that's not a lot, but the affected animals did suffer...) most, but not all, occurred when the reptile was able to get very close to the lamp.
I am told that probably because they are so cheap, Exoterra ReptiGlo tubes are the most popular brands on the market, so the incidence of injuries must be very low; the risk cannot be very great.
Hope that helps.
Frances
http://www.uvguide.co.uk
Now all that being said, personally I have never been a fan of Compacts, have always used tubes because I have always mounted the fixtures inside the enclosures. Compacts have their place, just not in any of 'my' enclosures .
Don't know if that actually answers your question or not, but that's all I got .